The All-Southern eleven representing the consensus of newspapers as published in Fuzzy Woodruff's A History of Southern Football 1890-1928 included:
Bob Blake, end for Vanderbilt, unanimous selection, was a lawyer and Rhodes Scholar selected for the Associated Press Southeast Area All-Time football team 1869-1919 era.[2][3]
Dan Blake, halfback for Vanderbilt, brother of Bob. He later coached.
Honus Craig, halfback for Vanderbilt, Dan McGugin once called him the South's greatest athlete and Vanderbilt's greatest halfback.[4] One report says "When Craig was confronted with the above formidable title yesterday by a reporter whose business it is to know such things, he blushed like a girl and tried to show why Dan McGugin's judgment is not always to be trusted."[4] In Craig's opinion, Bob Blake was the South's greatest player.[4]
Puss Derrick, guard and captain for Clemson. John de Saulles sums up Derrick's play in 1905; he "is a veteran player who, by steady improvement has put himself in the first rank of linesmen. He was the mainstay of the Clemson season and no other Southern player could so satisfactorily fill this important position; hence, to balance the team and utilize the best of the material available, he is shifted from center to guard."
Ed Hamilton, end for Vanderbilt, coached Vanderbilt basketball in 1903–1904 and 1908–1909
Frank Jones, tackle for Auburn, captain-elect for both football and basketball.
Frank Kyle, quarterback for Vanderbilt, once head coach at Ole Miss.
Owsley Manier, fullback for Vanderbilt, a "great plunging back."[2]
Robert C. Patterson, center for Vanderbilt, known as "Emma," he later coached at Georgia Military Academy and as an assistant for his alma mater in 1908.
Stein Stone, guard for Vanderbilt, as a center selected for the Associated Press Southeast Area All-Time football team 1869-1919 era.[3]
^"1905 V.P.I. Football team". Retrieved February 11, 2015.
^ abHenry Jay Case (1914). "Vanderbilt–A University of the New South". Outing. 64: 327 – via Google books.
^ ab"U-T Greats On All-Time Southeast Team". Kingsport Post. July 31, 1969.
^ abc""Honus" Craig, All-Southern Right Halfback---He Talks". Abilene Daily Reporter. April 25, 1909. Archived from the original on March 4, 2016. Retrieved March 8, 2015 – via University of North Texas.
^ abcdefW. R. Tichenor (December 3, 1905). "Football Experts Give Their Selections For An All-Southern Team". The Atlanta Constitution. Retrieved March 5, 2015 – via Newspapers.com.
^John Heisman (December 10, 1905). "Heisman's Selection of All-Southern Team". Atlanta Constitution. p. 1.